Military Finances 201: The Strangest Rule in the Tax Code
TaxesMost things in the tax code make sense to me (really). Some seem a little odd. But the rules concerning split returns in a community property state are just plain weird.
For most married taxpayers, their best option is to file their taxes jointly. The tax code, I think, is specifically written to encourage joint filing (half the workload for the IRS). But that doesn’t mean you should never file separately. Cases where it may make sense include when you have an Income Based Repayment plan for student loans in place or one spouse has low income and significant medical expenses during the year. There are, of course, other cases.
Splitting a Tax Return in a Community Property State
You decide that is beneficial for you to file separately; you split the return in TurboTax® and hit “send”. You might have just made a big mistake…if you live in a community property state. As a reminder, the community property states are:
- Arizona
- California
- Idaho
- Louisiana
- Nevada
- New Mexico
- Texas
- Washington
- Wisconsin
One or two (or 3) of those are pretty popular “resident” states for active-duty military members.
Here’s the rub. In a community property state, you can’t just “split” the return. You have to correct for the fact that in a community property state, for married couples, what yours is mine and what mine is yours. Literally. That means even if you file separately, you’ll have to account for community income on your tax return. Said another way, you’ll likely have to declare ½ of your income and ½ of your spouse’s income on your tax return and you’ll likely have to manually adjust your tax return to account for the community income.
What is Community Income?
To determine which income to adjust, you need to know what community income is. While not exhaustive, community income includes:
- Wages and salaries earned
- Bonuses and commissions
- Self-employment Income
- Interest Income (if generated by community property…property acquired while in a community property state)
- Dividends (same as interest)
- Capital Gains (same as interest)
- Rental Income (same as interest)
What isn't Community Income?
Not everything is community income. Here are some specific exclusions:
- Income from an asset owned before marriage
- Income from an asset received individually as a gift
- Income from an inherited asset inherited individually
- Social Security benefits
So, once you determine you have community income, how do you report it?
The short answer is you’ll complete the tax return with the adjusted income. Then, and this step is important, you’ll complete a Form 8958. The 8958 basically shows the IRS “your math”. To be honest, good luck figuring this out on TurboTax® (or any tax software for that matter). But it is the right way to file your return.
Other Considerations
You may determine that doing all this isn’t worth it and just file jointly. Or…you could move to a common law state; but even if you do move, the income on property acquired while a resident of a community property state maintains its community property/income status. Also, if you’re a resident of a community property state and PCS to a common law state, you’re still subject to the community property rules (if you don't change your residency). Good luck explaining that to your local HR Block tax preparer.
Military Finances are Different
Since your residency doesn't necessarily change when you PCS, you may be subject to these community property rules even if you live in a common law state. That isn't the only way military finances are different than civilian finances. That is why we think that you should work with a firm that deals with those issues each and every day. If you'd like to find out how we work with Active and Retired Senior Military Officers and NCOs, use the button below to schedule a free, initial consultation.
If you found this article useful, you might like the following blog posts:
Retired Military Finances 201: Charitable Giving Tax Treatment is Changing
Retired Military Finances 301: Inherited, Inherited IRAs: The Kobayashi Maru of Income Tax?
Retired Military Finances 201: Tax Loss Harvesting and Year-End Planning